Third Sunday of Easter
/Dominica III Paschae
Acts 5:27-32, 40b-41; Rev. 5:11-14; Jn. 21:1-19
4 May 2022
The person of St. Peter is a key figure in this Sunday’s Gospel passage. In addition to the person, we should consider the office of St. Peter, meaning the role of St. Peter, given to him by Christ Jesus. To that end it is very providential that we have today’s Gospel passage at the time of a Conclave because it shows us the mind of Christ for St. Peter and the office or role that would endure in the Lord’s Church. This resurrection appearance of Jesus is unique in that it takes place, not in Jerusalem, but at the Sea of Galilee, also called the Sea of Tiberias. In other words, this appearance takes place up in the north. It takes place in the general area where the apostles were from, and where they first received their calling to follow Jesus. We have all likely had experiences of revisiting familiar places from earlier in life. You can imagine that being back in their place of origin naturally called to mind for the apostles a reflection on where they had come from, and the journey they had been on with Jesus. It naturally brings to the forefront of their minds how Jesus had formed them, and how far they had come from their initial days of discipleship. And by necessity, when one reflects on his origins and how far he has come, one can’t help but think ahead to the future, the journey still to come. In this passage, St. Peter gets clear indications from Jesus about the path he is on, where his journey in service to the Lord will take him, and what it will demand of him.
This encounter of Peter with the resurrected Lord is full of the themes of repentance and restoration. The big clue to this is that St. John tells us that on the beach with Jesus there is a “charcoal fire”. That is a very specific word in Greek and the last time we encountered it was from St. John’s account of the Passion recorded in John 18 (verses 17-18; 25-27). In the passion account, Jesus had been arrested and was being interrogated. Nearby, at a charcoal fire, Peter was keeping himself warm and comfortable while he denied three times that he even knew the Lord. Thus, the charcoal fire in today’s passage carries over this imagery of threefold denial. I think the scene today can be characterized as showing signs of Peter’s repentance from that failure of denial. Though the boat he was in was not far from shore, Peter, upon hearing that it is Jesus on shore, does not wait to row in, but instead jumps into the chilly, early morning water and makes his way to Jesus. It’s a sign of repentance. He could have reasonably (and comfortably) waited. But, in a form of eager repentance, Peter tucks in his garment and jumps into the water to get to the Lord faster. There, on the shore, with the other figures faded into the background, he is again near the Lord in the light of a fire. The idea of repentance and restoration is still more clearly emphasized in the dialogue between Jesus and Peter. The three denials of Peter are echoed – yet undone – when Peter is asked three times to profess his love for Jesus. Where Peter had been looking out for himself and his own comfort during the Passion, now Jesus asks him, “Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these?” Simon Peter answered, “Yes, Lord, you know that I love you.” The Gospel doesn’t tell us this detail, but we do know it was dawn at this appearance, and so I have to wonder if somehow a rooster couldn’t be heard crowing somewhere in the distance, echoing across the lake, echoing the past denial. But the details we do know with authority are more than enough to capture this scene and its opportunity of restoration for Peter who had so grievously failed the Lord and the other apostles.
I want to drill down a bit deeper however. Because the indication of repentance and restoration of Peter is not simply found in the numerical evidence: a threefold denial now followed by a threefold profession of love and recommitment to Jesus. Jesus is clearly drawing Peter back in, back to himself. But there is a further sign of restoration that should not be lost on us. For Peter’s restoration was not simply accomplished in his words alone, where in this passage he now claims three times to love Jesus. Still more, his restoration comes about because in responding to Peter’s new recommitment, Jesus gives Peter a threefold charge. Peter professes love that undoes his prior denial, yes. But he is restored precisely in being given individually the role of shepherd. Upon professing his love, Jesus tells Peter three times: “Feed my lambs; Tend my sheep; Feed my sheep.” The Greek of St. John is even more direct. Rather than what we have in English as “tend my sheep”, St. John uses the word that strongly and directly means “shepherd my sheep”. In other words, be the shepherd! This resurrection appearance also directs Peter to the future. His love will be required of him by being led where he would prefer not to go and by stretching out his hands. St. John tells us that Jesus “said this signifying by what kind of death he would glorify God.”
St. Peter’s office, or role, continues among the Apostles and is maintained in the Catholic Church by divine institution. That our faith is guarded and proclaimed by a Church that is apostolic is a necessary mark of the Church established by Jesus. This Wednesday, in the morning in our time zone, the Cardinals who will vote to elect a pope will be sequestered in the Sistine Chapel for the Conclave. Hours before the Sistine Chapel doors are locked, we will gather here in the main church this Tuesday, at 5:30 pm, to pray the Mass for the Election of a Pope. I hope you will join us in this act of faith to invoke the Holy Spirit for the Conclave and to pray for the wisdom of the cardinals and their docility to do what will most glorify God. Soon, a new man will have his own reckoning like Peter on the lakeshore: thinking of where his life began, the journey he has been on, his past, and the future to which he is called by papal election. Soon, a new man will not be able to help but to have this final Sunday Gospel before the Conclave echoing in his mind: Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these? Whoever is called to take the place of Peter and to continue his office for our shepherding, we pray that the spirit of repentance may come upon him such that similar to Peter in the boat, that man may jump into the distinctive white garment of the Pope and so make his way to Jesus as quickly as he can, while he leads us to the Lord in his wake. We will pray that the one chosen is holy, and maybe even smart, and maybe even a good administrator and communicator. No doubt, the one chosen will be a sinner who may have his own past charcoal fires of denial. But, as the fire from burning ballots of his successful election send up white smoke for the world to see, we pray that the one elected may be restored and confirmed in the mission to be our chief visible shepherd on earth. As Peter himself was called to be dressed and to be led where he did not want to go in order to stretch out his hands in witness to Jesus, we pray that the man elected will stretch out his hands in blessing us and giving us the witness of dying to himself, dying to personal theologies and factions, so that we may have the generous and faithful love of a shepherd worth following because he is responding to Jesus who first said to Peter: Follow me!